An ordinary evening on the Brooklyn Bridge

This essay was first drafted on Nov. 20, when Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge posted a formal proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, perhaps the most important open problem in mathematics.

Today I walked the Brooklyn Bridge, and as I walked I felt a cool tongue of perfume and exhaust waft up from the river, from a girl who laughing passed me by. Today, an AI proved the Riemann Hypothesis.

I read this news on the Brooklyn side of the bridge, Manhattan still in the distance, and I remembered wistfully that one day long ago I dreamed of building an AI to do something similar, to write a proof that I knew I could never write myself.

That the Riemann Hypothesis is true—perhaps a relief. That an AI solved it, in code—well, if I had been a better mathematician I would have tried to work this way too, to suggest tactics and write proofs in collaboration with a machine.

I cannot read Claude’s proof, and even if I could read Lean I could hardly comment on its beauty or clarity or lack thereof. It is too big and too real. I only remember my complex analysis professor speaking of the critical line, of the music of the primes like jazz, transparencies of disorder so delicately constrained within order. I wonder where is the beauty of a proof I cannot read.

And as Manhattan rises before me, the Verizons and the Merrills and the many banks along the Hudson, I think to myself what’s the matter, that in San Francisco a brilliant man and his yet more brilliant helper have struck the bell of a new era?

The evening light ebbs down the waterfront. I walk and walk and walk. Another mathematician, I read, compares Claude to a telescope. More and more will be uncovered, he says. It is not the end of mathematics, or of mathematicians.

What’s the matter then? A man perched on the steel fence of the walkway looks up from his phone and almost meets my eye. What’s the matter with this industrialization of mathematics? What are we afraid of? That math might become like big physics, with a few ensconced in rich labs with their tools and helpers while the remainder retreat to theory?—well, there’s nothing wrong per se with big physics, and it is not as if math does not have its elites. That even ‘theory’ is no recourse for pure math, and those without resources will not be mathematicians but philosophers?—well, there’s also nothing wrong with philosophy per se, though it is not math.

What are we afraid of? Of being scooped?—we were always afraid of being scooped. Perhaps it is that even those mathematicians with resources will be reduced to a bitter remainder, solving mainly for how many tokens it will take to generate a proof.

My old supervisor Gromov once said to me, a mathematician is defined by two things: freedom, because there are so many problems to work on and you can choose to work on any one of them, and desperation, because there are so many problems to work on and so you should look everywhere you can for help.

God, I am tired, and I need help. The day grows long, the ferries are heading home, and just how many problems do I need to solve? And how much money will I need to solve them? I do not like this grubby, bitter calculation. This is not what I want to work on, these hammered divisions of divisions of value, rummaging through a thin rump of problems left over by the trillion-dollar companies. I would rather dream of an experimental mathematics, a new Galilean age where we take like tall-sailed ships across the amber sea, spyglasses out in search of continents.

What are we afraid of? Perhaps it is that mathematics, which once felt so large, suddenly feels so small. The sun floods the horizon, merging into the far piers out west in Jersey. As I walk I wonder, is the beauty of a proof that somewhere within it is another question? Then where is the beauty of a proof I cannot question, I wonder, as I walk off the bridge and rejoin the city, as I walk into the people, the gorgeous people of this city, young and wrinkled white and brown veiled and bare, children red hearted for New York.